Responsibility for non-disclosure of genital herpes? | ScriptaLegal
Personal Business Packages & Subscriptions
Français About us Create a free account Log in
Interactive legal guides Legal frequently asked questions Legal blog Videos
ONLINE LEGAL DOCUMENTS
Legal blog > Marriage > Responsibility in not disclosing that one is a carrier of genital herpes

Responsibility in not disclosing that one is a carrier of genital herpes

Transparency is supposed to be, nowadays, the mantra of all relationships, both professional and romantic, yet doesn't everyone have the right to their own little privacy?

«Small gifts keep friendship alive»
Decoly

Transparency is supposed to be the leitmotiv of all relationships nowadays, whether in a professional or romantic setting. However, doesn't everyone have the right to their own little secret garden?

For instance, a couple in their sixties develops a romantic relationship. Both parties got divorced over thirty years ago and have had long-term romantic relationships since then. Although they don't live together, their relationship evolves and, going from words to actions, they engage in unprotected sexual intercourse.

After a few months, the woman starts experiencing pain and itching in her genital area. "She notifies the man, who then reveals that he has been carrying herpes for over ten years. Their relationship continues, and a year later, the man announces to the woman that he is interested in another woman. This leads to a breakup." The woman, after consulting a specialist, is obliged to take daily medication. She informs the man, who apologizes in writing, expresses remorse, and includes $200 with his letter. Three months pass, and the woman takes the matter to court* and sues the man for over $145,000.

The court concludes that the man "committed a fault that establishes liability by not disclosing to the woman that he was a carrier of genital herpes." The woman was unable to adequately inform herself and make an informed decision. Therefore, the man committed a fault that resulted in his liability. However, the woman lacked caution and vigilance, as she took risks herself, which means she must bear 50% of the responsibility for the damages she suffered.

In business as well as in love, your garden can never remain a secret if you don't watch who lingers there. Let's remember that we are always responsible for our actions; it is up to each individual to know the other party before accepting a gift because not all gifts are necessarily presents.

*Court case number: C.S. 505-17-002724-062

François Forget, notary and legal advisor as well as the entire Notaire-Direct team, are at your service to ensure the preparation of your legal documents and answer all your legal questions.
Acquired rights vs Respect for neighbors
Me François Forget - April 10, 2019
As urban agglomerations expand, certain industries take refuge in their acquired rights by invoking the precedence...
The assets owned by one of the spouses before the marriage
Me François Forget - August 23, 2005
When a spouse purchases a property using the proceeds from the sale of a property they owned before the marriage,...
We must take advantage of the benefits provided by the contract at the appropriate time and place, otherwise, it's already too late!
Me François Forget - April 12, 2017
We must take advantage of the benefits granted by contract when and where they are offered, otherwise, it is...

This browser does not support this kind of file. Please download the file to view it: Download the file