Weight of a 12-year-old child's intention in shared custody? | ScriptaLegal
Personal Law Business Law Packages & Subscriptions
Français About us Create a free account Log in
Interactive legal guides Legal frequently asked questions Legal blog Videos
ONLINE LEGAL DOCUMENTS
Legal blog > Marriage > The significance of the intention expressed by a 12-year-old child through their shared custody

The significance of the intention expressed by a 12-year-old child through their shared custody

The expressed intention of a child over 12 years old to live with one parent rather than the other is a significant factor.

«The roads are pretty bad, without throwing more stones at us»
Florian

Children, beyond the daily concerns, are a source of joy that, from a peaceful path, can sometimes quickly transform into a bumpy road, dotted with roller coaster-like disputes and settling of scores between parents.

Thus, a couple who have lived together for more than fifteen years separate and, by mutual agreement, agree that their eldest son will live with his father and that their minor children will live with their mother. One year after the conclusion of this agreement, the eldest of the minor children, who is then 12 and a half years old, decides to "stay one week out of two" with her father despite her mother's opposition. The father, who was denied joint custody in the first instance, turns to the Court of Appeal*.

The Court concludes that, although case law recognizes the first instance judge's discretionary power, "this discretion must be exercised taking into account the best interests of the child", a cardinal rule in this matter. This interest will be assessed according to three factors: firstly, the parental capacity of each parent, secondly, the time and resources that parents are willing to devote to the well-being of their children and, finally, the absence of contraindications such as geographical, health or psychological reasons.

In addition, the court states that, without being exclusive, the intention expressed by a child over the age of 12 to live with one parent rather than the other is largely determinative, but there is no presumption in favor of joint custody unless it is considered in light of the parental capacity of both parents. The Court decides to grant joint custody for the eldest daughter.

Whether it's a peaceful path or a bumpy road, parents, children and the judge must strive not to end up in the ditch and maintain the course in order to avoid potholes as much as possible in a child custody request.

*C.A. Québec 200-09-005781-064

François Forget, notary and legal advisor as well as the entire Notaire-Direct team, are at your service to ensure the preparation of your legal documents and answer all your legal questions.
A text that appears clear on its face can give rise to interpretation
Me François Forget - April 9, 2014
A "text that appears clear on its face can lead to interpretation when it becomes apparent that what is expressed...
As seen, does not equate to a waiver of the seller's warranty
Me François Forget - March 23, 2009
The sale or purchase of a property can sometimes turn out to be a pot of little bitter surprises.
The purpose of a non-competition clause
Me François Forget - January 20, 2005
The difficulty of enforcing a non-compete clause in a contract is inversely proportional to the good faith of the...

This browser does not support this kind of file. Please download the file to view it: Download the file