Company administrator must act in good faith | ScriptaLegal
Personal Law Business Law Packages & Subscriptions
Français About us Create a free account Log in
Interactive legal guides Legal frequently asked questions Legal blog Videos
ONLINE LEGAL DOCUMENTS
Legal blog > Company > The administrator of a company must act in good faith

The administrator of a company must act in good faith

An administrator must act in good faith and cannot declare a dividend that operates a disguised liquidation contrary to the company's bylaws.

«Forgetting is the indispensable condition for memory»
Alfred Jarry

By allowing the formation of a company, the law has certainly limited the liability of shareholders, but in return it has established certain rules that both the company and the directors and shareholders must adhere to.

A father wishing to retire transfers the shares he holds in a tannery to 2 management companies owned by his 2 sons who have been working with him for over 30 years. In return, each management company issues him 1000 non-voting shares, redeemable at a commercially reasonable fair price and eligible for a dividend of $0.50 per share. The father, ignoring his 2 sons, bequeaths his freeze shares to his other children.

In the years following the father's death, the 2 management companies declare 2 dividends, one of $0.50 per freeze share and another of $845 per "A" share owned by the 2 sons. The other children then turn to the court and demand, among other things, that the declared dividends be cancelled.

Even though the courts recognize "the validity of a provision authorizing a discretionary dividend," "such a provision does not eliminate the obligation of directors to act in good faith and in the best interests of the company."

The Court of Appeal* comes to the conclusion that the declared dividend cannot be justified in the interest of the companies. "They are carrying out a disguised liquidation contrary to the companies' bylaws." The court therefore orders that the dividends be returned to the management companies.

Some company directors tend to forget their obligations. Why do we have to turn to the courts to remind them?

*C.A. 500-09-001513-928 and 500-09-001517-929, 1998-06-18

François Forget, notary and legal advisor as well as the entire Notaire-Direct team, are at your service to ensure the preparation of your legal documents and answer all your legal questions.
Legal warranty on a ancestral residence over 150 years old
Me François Forget - November 9, 2016
Buying a home is stressful for the majority of people. However, for most sellers, it is rather a liberating act...
Insurance and the principle of proportional indemnity
Me François Forget - June 22, 2009
In life, everyone has their own values, but don't forget that in times of trouble, insurers have values...
A trust cannot be used as an escape route
Me François Forget - January 22, 2008
The creation of a trust cannot be used as an escape route for a parent to avoid fulfilling their child support...

This browser does not support this kind of file. Please download the file to view it: Download the file