The purchase offer for a building must be precise. | ScriptaLegal
Personal Law Business Law Packages & Subscriptions
Français About us Create a free account Log in
Interactive legal guides Legal frequently asked questions Legal blog Videos
ONLINE LEGAL DOCUMENTS
Legal blog > Real estate > The purchase offer for a property must be precise

The purchase offer for a property must be precise

The purchase offer for a property must be precise. Failing to be so, each party may interpret it in the way they wish to understand it.

«The information doesn't have to be true or false; it has to be accurate»
Jacques Lacan

The offer to purchase a property must be precise. If it is not, each party can interpret it in whichever way they have understood it.

Thus, a hotel owner wishing to sell their complex assigns a real estate broker for this purpose. Several months pass and the broker finds a buyer whose offer is duly accepted by the hotel owner. This offer is conditional on the verification of the financial statements for the past three years and an inspection of the property, to the satisfaction of the buyer, all within a fifteen-day period. The buyer, dissatisfied with the received financial statements, requests updated statements. The parties sign an amended offer delaying the signing of the deed of sale by 45 days and verbally agree that the updated statements will be provided to the buyer. As these were never given to the buyer, they refuse to sign the deed of sale and inform the broker that they are withdrawing their offer since the complex's income is $135,000 lower than what the broker presented.

Following this withdrawal, the broker claims their commission from the buyer, amounting to over $60,000, which the trial court awards them. The case is brought to appeal* and the court reverses the decision by specifying that the conditions stipulated in the offer were not met to the satisfaction of the buyer, who had the right to refuse to purchase and, as such, the broker cannot claim their commission that they would have been entitled to if the sale had taken place. The court justifies its decision by relying on two reasons:

  • Firstly, even though the hotel owner provided the financial statements for the past three years, the offer stipulated that these had to be to the satisfaction of the buyer. Contrary to what the trial judge states, the buyer's satisfaction applied not only to the inspection of the property but also to the financial statements. The court reminds that the Quebec Civil Code provides that in interpreting a contract, one must always "take into account its nature and the circumstances in which it was concluded";
  • Secondly, the case law is clear: if the deadlines are not strictly stipulated, a buyer is not obliged to sign within those provided in the offer to purchase. In this case, the mentioned deadlines for the signing of the deed of sale allowed the buyer to only sign if they declared themselves satisfied with the financial statements.

Even though "reading is always interpreting," writing well means ensuring that what we have written will be interpreted according to what we meant to say.

*CA 500-09-022522-122

François Forget, notary and legal advisor as well as the entire Notaire-Direct team, are at your service to ensure the preparation of your legal documents and answer all your legal questions.
Once the agreement is signed, it becomes less easy to escape one's commitment!
Me François Forget - January 31, 2018
It is common for a couple to draft a written agreement in the event of their divorce.
Respecting physical distancing means prioritizing virtual meetings
Me François Forget - January 12, 2021
Your notarized will and protection mandate can now be received via videoconference by a notary with...
Mortgage used to secure existing or potential obligations
Me François Forget - June 25, 2013
Every second lien lender should inquire not only about the amount of the mortgage, but also about the nature of...

This browser does not support this kind of file. Please download the file to view it: Download the file