The usefulness of an arbitration clause | ScriptaLegal
Personal Law Business Law Packages & Subscriptions
Français About us Create a free account Log in
Interactive legal guides Legal frequently asked questions Legal blog Videos
ONLINE LEGAL DOCUMENTS
Legal blog > Mediation & Arbitration > The usefulness of an arbitration clause

The usefulness of an arbitration clause

In Quebec, if there is an arbitration clause in a contract, the parties to a contract must comply with the rules established therein.

«The usual flaw of man is not to anticipate the storm in good weather»
Nicolas Machiavel

It is not uncommon for people who associate and sign a unanimous shareholder agreement to later refuse to honor the agreement on various pretexts.

Two brothers-in-law who hold equal shares in a company sign a unanimous shareholder agreement. One of them, disabled following an accident, becomes unable to fulfill his obligations towards the company.

The unanimous agreement provides that any shareholder who is prevented from fulfilling his duties for a period of two years due to illness must irrevocably offer all his shares to his co-shareholder.

Two years pass and the "disabled" receives a written acceptance of the automatic offer provided for in the shareholder agreement from the "healthy" one. Refusing the proposed price, the "disabled" invokes the arbitration clause provided in the agreement. The arbitrator, while recognizing the validity of the offer, sets the value of the shares at more than four times the price offered by the "healthy" one. The latter approaches the Court* and requests the cancellation of the sale. The judge rejects the claims of the "healthy" one since "accepting such a request would amount to denying the existence of the unanimous shareholder agreement and the arbitration clause aimed at resolving disputes".

When there is an arbitration clause, should not the parties comply with the established rules, the first being to respect the arbitrator's mandate. Thus, the claims of the "healthy" one were invalidated, and the "disabled" is all the better off.

*C.S. 150-05-002774-018, 2002-02-06   

François Forget, notary and legal advisor as well as the entire Notaire-Direct team, are at your service to ensure the preparation of your legal documents and answer all your legal questions.
A shareholders' agreement aims to prevent disputes
Me François Forget - June 13, 2019
It often happens that entrepreneurs start a company without worrying about signing a shareholders' agreement. Such...
A contract is like a sauce, you have to balance the ingredients!
Me François Forget - March 31, 2004
When there is doubt, a contract is interpreted in favor of the party who assumed the obligation.
Marriage is a lifelong commitment
Me François Forget - October 24, 2003
Marriage is based on the idea of mutual support rather than independence, advocating for prolonged spousal support.

This browser does not support this kind of file. Please download the file to view it: Download the file